Another great read from Paul Farrell. I do not even know where to start, there is so much flawed logic in Ayn Rand ideas. From the article:
”
Worse, we also know leaders armed with “wrong theories” can do lots of damage in the name of their ideologies. So take a moment, compare the following Bridgewater’s “Principles” with Rand’s earlier description of capitalism. My challenges are italicized. Then ask yourself: “What’s The Truth?” …
Dalio: “Self-interest and society’s interests are generally symbiotic: more than anything else, it is pursuit of self interest that motivates people to push themselves to do the difficult things that benefit them and that contribute to society.” [Is that really true? Does individual self-interest always make the best contribution to society in general? Or is that just an unproven, possibly even “wrong theory?”]
Dalio: “In return, society rewards those who give it what it wants. That is why how much money people have earned is a rough measure of how much they gave society what it wanted.” [Ask yourself: Is it really true that society as a whole wants unregulated derivatives as much as Goldman Sachs’s executives?]
Dalio: “Look at what caused people to make a lot of money and you will see that usually it is in proportion to their production of what the society wanted.” [Ask yourself: Is it true that a Lloyd Blankfein produces more of what society really wants than, for example, a Steve Jobs, Daniel Kahneman, Rod Stewart or Dalai Lama?]
Dalio: “There are many people who have made a lot of money who never made making a lot of money their primary goal.” [But isn’t it true that “making a lot of money” is the main goal of the financial industry, its insiders and stockholders?]
Dalio: “There is an excellent correlation between giving society what it wants and making money, and almost no correlation between the desire to make money and how much money one makes. I know that this is true for me.” [But is this really true for the other 99% of Americans, tens of millions unemployed or living in poverty?]
Dalio: “So what is success? I believe that it is nothing more than getting what you want — and that it is up to you to decide what that is for you.” [But is it really true that you can omit what’s best for society at large from a success equation, by assuming that some magical “invisible hand” plus the collective selfishness of individuals will guarantee the public interest is best served? Or could this be a “wrong theory?”]
”
read the whole thing at link below. I would really like to see honest discussion on this one.
SOURCE:
http://www.marketwatch.com/story/top-hedge-fund-mixes-ayn-rand-behavioral-psych-2011-09-27
GotWake 12:41 pm on September 28, 2011 234 days ago Reply
It’s funny how some people will b@tch about anything. “Wildly ambitious”? This moron doesn’t know Apple very well. They just revolutionized 2 industries in four years, I think they may know what they are doing.