There is this big front page article on Huffington Post (which I generally like to read) titled ROTTEN TO THE CORE (and Apple logo) pointing to a critical article in New York Times about conditions of Chinesse workers working on Apple products.
I was looking at that and was thinking to myself – where the fuck people do you think is the rest of the stuff you buy made. Give me a break targeting Apple for working conditions in a developing country. As they will become developed country their conditions will improve. I find it extremely silly to be comparing conditions of workers in developing countries to workers conditions in developed countries. I am pretty sure that working at Foxconn is for many migrant workers a great improvement from poverty in rural areas. Sure I wish them to have better conditions but like every other country (or individual), they will have to get there.
-
-
(Cut n paste of my comment from PED’s blog on CNN)
The Q4 2011 “miss” made me look long and hard at where I, the analysts, and the bloggers went wrong.
It all comes down to a single data point – listen to Peter Oppenheimer! Always! He telegraphed in no uncertain terms that they would come in light, guiding $5.50.
For this Q just in he did the same – he was shouting it out loud and clear that it would be a monumental quarter, guiding at $9.30.
Looking at (thanks PED!) the historical (back to mid 2006) beat over guidance, we get a range of 19 to 61%. At guidance of $9.30, and using the lowest beat of 19%, we get $11.07, a full dollar over Street consensus. Using the upper third, or a 50% beat, we get almost exactly the actual result of $13.87. And FYI, that “miss” was still a 28% beat of their own guidance.
The analyst who predicted that Apple would miss their *own* guidance should be fired on the spot.
This range is golden, and Oppy’s guidance is everything. The only fiddling that we, the investing public, need do is to gauge whether it was a good or great quarter and accordingly adjust where on the 19 to 61% range we should be sliding the needle.
So, heads up for next Q. At guidance of $8.50 we arrive at an EPS range of $10.11 to $13.69. Don’t let anybody say we weren’t all warned in advance!
-
EPS 13.87$
Rev. $46.33B
GM 44.7%iPhone 37M
iPad 15.4M
Mac 5.2M
iPod 15.4M -
-
Tesla received some tax credit from California ($23.7M) and is planning to invest $292M to expand manufacturing for Model X and battery / power train for Toyota Rav4 EV, while creating 1,237 jobs (they are very precise!). (Dow Jones Venturewire – sorry, no link)
Now they have estimated in the past that total cost of bringing the Model X to the market is about $150M because they leverage the Model S platform. A drivable prototype will be unveiled on Feb. 9 so a large chunk of those $150M development costs have already been spent.
So what I see here is a confirmation of the $1B or so order from Toyota they hinted to last summer but probably got an iron fist from their partner in their mouth (the supplier and generally the smaller partner does not announce a deal).
-
It’s amazing it took this long. But, it’s too little, too late.
-
This is the one weekness that Apple has. They have not needed PR until now, but now they need it. And they need to take a lead on this issue. These jobs ARE gone, but industry isn’t. Apple is the one cpany that uses this supply chain to the best advantage. Other companies use it to build race-to-the-bottom engines.
Sadly, we’re no longer a manufacturing nation, so we will fumble with this issue before we can understand it. Henry Ford wouldn’t know would be stunned at how we’ve changed.
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/22/business/apple-america-and-a-squeezed-middle-class.html
-
In my December Quo Vadis post I argued for DJIA go higher in January. You can see it here. Since then DJIA is up 338 points (2.75%)
http://www.traderhood.com/2011/12/27/quo-vadis
Gold behaved as I expected too. It rose above the it’s 1,600 resistance and is hanging at 1,658 at a moment. Gain of 3.62%.
EUR was real slow to gain as it was pounded daily with negative rhetoric in financial periodicals. On top of it S&P downgraded almost every European country with exception of Germany (and Slovakia) and Fitch is daily fear mongering the news with Greek default. In spite of all of that EUR finally started to gain and was able to bounce off the lows of 1.2623 and make 4 day uninterrupted bullish run to 1.2971. This is the first time since the beginning of November 2011 it was able to finish full uninterrupted stochastic upswing on dailies. Not even the S&P downgrade of the “whole” Europe could push it lower.
That said, I think EUR will get a short breather here before it can continue higher. I’ll be watching how far it will retrace now that stochastic on dailies is at 80%. A lot of the EUR will be again influenced by media, but my guess is now that it has been able to do full stochastic bounce, it will not retrace more than 50% and I will be increasing my EUR positions on resistance breakouts.
Both DJIA and gold seems to be slightly on overbought side and I would expect both of them to pull back a bit with DJIA having support at 12,250 and gold having support around 1,620.
AAPL is technically at overbought levels and I think a lot of the earnings news is already priced in upfront. Unless Apple posts totally unexpected (higher than any expectation) earnings, there will be the “buy rumor – sell news” pullback after the announcement.
-
necessary correction in GOOG after missing estimates + quarterly EPS growth of 6.3% y/y
even so, their P/E will be nicely above 18 tomorrow with anemic growthwith a P/E of 18 (and growth north of 80% y/y), AAPL would be about $600 on Wednesday after earnings – not gonna happen; but I maintain my prediction that by the end of the year one share of AAPL will be more expensive to buy than one GOOG
-




conshmillo 8:11 am on January 26, 2012 11 days ago Reply
btw. Foxconn factory is actually city of 230,000 people. it is bound to have certain amount of accidents as any place of that size would have. It makes you really think who would have interest day after announcing stellar results to attack Apple in particular for things that go for every single product made in China. In Huffington Post this was the MAIN article of their site at the same level as yesterday Obama’s state of Union was (which was great) Somebody is trying hard to smear Apple. Maybe Android fanboys think their products are made by unionized workers with free health care in Fresno…
GotWake 12:45 pm on January 26, 2012 10 days ago Reply
Yes, I get so fucking tired of hearing about this too. They forget:
Acer Inc.
Amazon
ASRock
Asus
Barnes & Noble
Cisco
Dell
EVGA Corporation
Hewlett-Packard
Intel
IBM
Lenovo
Logitech
Microsoft
MSI
Motorola
Netgear
Nintendo
Nokia
Panasonic
Philips
Sharp
Sony Ericsson
Toshiba
Vizio
People are so noble up until it affects their wallet. I wonder how long a company like Panasonic would last if it sold products at a 70% premium to Sharp for the same product just to have “Made in the USA” on it? I’m betting the company would go under and the Huffington Post would be posting articles on how the company couldn’t compete.
eatingbeets 3:10 pm on January 26, 2012 10 days ago Reply
Not to mention that Apple single-handedly funded a 20% raise for the entire Foxconn workforce in 2010. Pretty generous gesture IMO.
Source:
http://www.dailytech.com/Report+Apple+Cuts+07+Percent+of+iPad+Profit+to+Give+Factory+Workers+Big+Raise/article18571.htm
Senator Gronk 4:00 pm on January 26, 2012 10 days ago Reply
Not to mention the fact that 1 iPhone can replace 5 other household devices. I haven’t bought a timer, stopwatch, alarm clock, car stereo, nav system, small tv for the bedroom, etc. Because I have an iPhone. Sure, I’m reaching a bit, but let’s look at the waste before we piss and moan about the winner. Apple might be helping more than it’s hurting.
nolavabo 7:45 pm on January 26, 2012 10 days ago Reply
I noticed that in many of the stories that covered the recent mass suicide threat by Foxconn workers that no mention was made that they worked in the *exclusively* Xbox plant, instead continuing to describe Foxconn as the iPhone assembler.
Apple is the only tech company to join the Fair Labor Association. This is where you provide the FLA a complete list of your suppliers, and they in turn monitor the work conditions, posting any abuses or violations that they find on their website.
Apple may not deserve praise for this, as we do not know the true motivations behind it. In many ways it is the minimum that any large corporation should do. Is it merely responding to public pressure from stories such as this one in the NYT? Or do they genuinely have concern for these workers? Regardless of why, however, Apple certainly does not deserve to be criticised without a comparison being made to the rest of the tech industry.
JPWatkins 7:48 pm on January 26, 2012 10 days ago Reply
It annoys me that they specifically target Apple. But Apple has asked for it by touting their superiority in this area. Apple has been hypocritical and has been positioning themselves for “plausible deniability” rather than “right livelihood.” This actually goes strongly against their brand and it will cause harm to it.
It really pisses me off that Apple execs have trashed american workers and manufacturing and that Steve said, “Those jobs are never coming back.” While there is a kernel of truth to their mindset, it’s way out of alignment with reality. It’s all about what is expedient for Apple, not what is actually true. A company as big and influential as Apple creates the norm by their actions, whether for good or bad. A 20% raise is significant, but it only brought workers wages up to $0.40/hour.
It’s great that the design, engineering, etc. is done in the US, but they need to consider bringing appropriate portions of the manufacturing back to the US. Many other companies have found it to be the smart and economical thing to do WRT costs, convenience and quality, so I’m skeptical of Apple’s position on this.
Nicu 8:26 pm on January 26, 2012 10 days ago Reply
http://bit.ly/xbPotN
Nicu 8:27 pm on January 26, 2012 10 days ago Reply
sorry, not that one
http://bit.ly/yqzlYy
Nicu 8:29 pm on January 26, 2012 10 days ago Reply
everybody hates the winner, especially the competition which is getting literally killed by Apple (m$, nok, nintendo, moto, rim, goog soon, htc, sony to some extent, hp, dell, acer, asus etc.)
JPWatkins 11:26 pm on January 26, 2012 10 days ago Reply
I heard on NPR a few days ago that some clever young Indian folks developed a phone game for distribution (for free) in India that educates people not to take part in some activity. I think it may have had to do with dowries for brides or even killing brides if dowries are not paid (sorry I can’t remember exactly.) Pretty creative.
In any case, Apple needs to consider carefully what kind of a company they want to be in the eyes of their customers.
Richard 9:05 pm on January 26, 2012 10 days ago Reply
You are ever so right, Conshmillo! Our world is not perfect, and Apple has been pretty darned good recently on worker conditions AND on environmental impact.
Zee 4:52 am on January 27, 2012 10 days ago Reply
Smearing won’t work. Apart from people learning about who does and doesn’t do the offshore thing, the bottom line is that it’s legal. People must realize that change will occur. The movement of nations is never painless or easy. I feel that Apple’s influence has led and is worthy of respect. I think that Apple’s success is what’s really bugging people.
Nicu 9:11 am on January 27, 2012 10 days ago Reply
http://parislemon.com/post/16561630035/this-is-why-we-cant-have-nice-things
Nicu 2:07 pm on January 27, 2012 9 days ago Reply
one of the 10% MDN takes I agree with lately, which is more or less what I have said yesterday, only more artistically
http://macdailynews.com/2012/01/27/apple-ceo-tim-cook-we-care-about-every-worker-in-our-supply-chain/
Nicu 2:20 pm on January 27, 2012 9 days ago Reply
http://www.appleinsider.com/articles/12/01/27/chinese_respond_to_report_on_apples_suppliers_in_china.html
Nicu 2:23 pm on January 27, 2012 9 days ago Reply
every thinking person can reach the conclusions, but sometimes it is just easier to see what those from inside say; if you never saw children who are hungry, it’s probably hard to imagine how life is in China
JPWatkins 9:12 pm on January 30, 2012 6 days ago Reply
I doubt that it’s Apple’s rivals who are doing this, but otherwise that takes sounds pretty true.
In fact it’s probably more that people just love to hate the successful cocky company (or just any company that they love.) It’s a weird psychological behavior.
Again what bothers me most (aside from desperate people having few good choices and bing taken advantage of) is that this whole story is being told as “Apple does X” but, as is consistent with my first point, that’s what sells the papers, magazines, and TV (even if you consume it on your iPad!)
Nicu 8:07 pm on January 29, 2012 7 days ago Reply
“Boycotting Apple for better Foxconn wages and conditions is like having sex for virginity. Entirely counter-productive and exactly the wrong thing to be doing.”
http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2012/01/29/the-apple-boycott-people-are-spouting-nonsense-about-chinese-manufacturing/2/
Nicu 8:08 pm on January 29, 2012 7 days ago Reply
http://www.appleinsider.com/articles/12/01/29/labor_advocate_challenges_accuracy_of_nyt_report_on_apple_foxconn.html
Nicu 6:31 am on January 31, 2012 6 days ago Reply
http://micgadget.com/21420/thousands-line-up-for-foxconns-jobs-in-zhengzhou/